Auckland Therapy Counselling and Psychotherapy

Suppression of Emotion
Monique Nyemecz & Dr Stephen Appel

Introduction

The ability to suppress emotions and thoughts varies considerably from one individual to another (Werman, 1983). Suppression has been defined by Werman as the “volitional elimination or diminution from consciousness, by any means, of undesirable thoughts, feelings, or bodily sensations” (p. 413). The study of thought suppression has grown into a significant area of scientific inquiry. What has compelled the interest of the scientific community is the realisation that “suppression is not simply an ineffective tactic of mental control; it is counterproductive, helping assure the very mental state one had hoped to avoid” (Wenzlaff & Wegner, 2000, p. 59).

Constant Effort

Individuals often suppress emotional thoughts that arouse negative emotions as a way of regulating mood and reducing distress (Petrie, et al., 1998). According to Booth and Petrie, the suppression of emotions requires ongoing psychological effort in order to accommodate the disparity between what one is feeling and what one is experiencing. This effort indicates an increase in sympathetic nervous system activity which may have unhealthy consequences if becomes habitual. The constant suppression of emotions affects the neuroimmune network resulting in immunosuppression, leading to adverse health outcomes, says Booth (2005).

Suppression = Depression

Wegner’s (1992) study on “Instructed thought suppression” found paradoxically that the instruction to suppress a thought typically induces a remarkable preoccupation with that thought, and that the resultant sensitivity to these thoughts heightens emotionality. Furthermore Wegner recorded that during suppression of emotional thoughts, intrusive recurrences are associated over time with electrodermal responses. The conclusion is that emotional thoughts that are suppressed cause stronger psychophysiological responses than those that are not suppressed. Subsequent research measuring the tendency to suppress unwanted thoughts (Wegner & Zanakos, 1994) augments prior findings that suppression may be a precursor of psychopathological reactions ranging from obsession to depression to anxiety. Wegner and Zanakos conclude that the tendency to dislike negative thoughts and to react to them with suppression is associated with depression severity, and they suggest that thought suppression is therefore a useful way of understanding how people may become depression-prone.

Impaired Immune Functions

The emergence in recent decades of the discipline of psychoneuroimmunology has advanced knowledge of the relationship between psychosocial factors, the central nervous system, the immune system, and disease (Keller, Schleifer, Barlett, Shiflett, & Rameshwar, 2000). It is now known that psychological experiences such as stress and anxiety can influence immune function, which in turn may have an effect on disease development and progression (Azar, 1999).

Health Benefits

The idea that emotions and physiology mutually influence one another suggests that the immune system as part of our physiology may be affected by the expression of emotion (Booth, 2005). The expression and non-expression of emotion has been studied in chronic illness and in the quality of life of people living with or recovering from illnesses (Lepore & Smyth, 2002). Research findings provide strong evidence that the health benefits of emotional disclosure may result partially from effects on immune function (Booth & Petrie, 2002). As our emotions change, “the structure of our bodies changes and we experience our lives differently” (Booth & Petrie, 2002, p. 159). In other words, physiological changes accompany expression and suppression of emotions.

Find a Therapist

All of our therapists deal with emotional suppression and expression. Contact any of our Auckland Therapists for more information or an appointment.

Suppression in psychoneuroimmunology studies is one topic covered in an article for publication entitled “The death instinct: Suppression of emotions, physiology, and illness” written by Monique Nyemecz and Dr Stephen Appel. If you would like a copy of the article or reference details please email Monique at monique@psyche-therapy.co.nz.